Omar's Pizza

Had a straight up cheese pizza slice and it was spectacular. Quality stuff when just a cheese pizza hits all the marks. Easy parking available too. Would recommend to my local friends.

Published a month ago

I liked the variety of toppings they had as well as the crust. They can do half half but you have to call. Garlic knots looked like a ton of flavor but was on the bland side however the dough was good. The boneless wings with bbq didn’t taste like bbq at all. Overall just okay.

Published a year ago

My favorite pizza in all of LA county. So Good!

Published a month ago

Was surprised by the respectable prices. Ma & Pa pizza shops usually charge a lot more, as most people are fine paying for cheap chain pizza made of ingredients from a factory. To go with the food prices is a great pizza! Way better than expected. The $8.99 for 2 slices and a soda is perfect for the after school kids to meet up after school. My son said it was some of the best garlic toast he's ever had too. I will be returning.

Published a year ago

Great service, very friendly and most importantly really good pizza. Love it

Published 5 years ago

The food was absolutely amazing, I'm normally very picky about the bread used for pizza but the one I got was almost like a well done thin crust. Crunchy, full of sauce and topping they don't hold back like other places I've been to. The atmosphere of the place gives it a really chill vibe. If you have the time and sizable party I definitely recommend stopping by here. Plus I won a little box from the claw machine which is rare for me :D

Published a year ago

I had two LARGE Slices of mushroom, sausage and pepperoni pizza. Delicious 😋 I'll be back again soon. The hard part will be deciding what to have. I want more pizza, but there are so many other things on the menu that look So Good!

Published a year ago

So I decided to take a chance on this location due to the fact it was one of the few places open on Christmas. I should’ve taken heed to the previous substandard reviews. I ordered an Xtra large 5 cheese pepperoni pizza, 10 honey bbq wings, and an order of potato wedges. The potato wedges seemed to be tasteless and refried in old oil. The wings had to be doctored with other seasonings. The cheese pizza was below average and not worth the nearly $40!!!
I’m gonna chalk this experience up to it being on Christmas Day. There was no enjoyment for this food while watching Christmas Day football and basketball. I gave this location a one star because it was actually open on Christmas Day. Buyers and Italian food lovers beware!!!

Published a year ago

Published 13 days ago

Had a straight up cheese pizza slice and it was spectacular. Quality stuff when just a cheese pizza hits all the marks. Easy parking available too. Would recommend to my local friends.

Published a month ago

Published a month ago

My favorite pizza in all of LA county. So Good!

Published a month ago

Published a year ago

Published 3 months ago

Finally found a good pizza place

Published 3 months ago

Best pizza in Arcadia!

Published 4 months ago

Published 5 months ago

Published 6 months ago

Published 7 months ago

Small mom and pop pizza place. Pizza was NY style pizza, it was Ok.. give it a try and judge for yourself

Published 8 months ago

Probé varias cosas, pizza, calzone, pasta Alfredo, no me acuerdo el nombre de la otra pasta, pero muy rico todo.

Published 8 months ago

Published 9 months ago

Great food. Lunch special 2 slices of pizza and a fountain drink ..it's 🔥 2 👍 up .

Published 9 months ago

Great undercarriage, 0 flop, great sauce, good cheese, and a great crisp. 8.6

Published 10 months ago

My favorite to go for the calzone with ricotta and mozzarella🫶🏻

Published a year ago

Pizza is still very good but c'mon antipasto has minimal meats!!! Compare what I got (in to go container) to what they show as their example (the plate). Maybe one salami cut into shreds and i can count the pepperoni! C'mon owner get your ship straight!

Published a year ago

Published a year ago

Quiet place for pizza. The pizza was yummy but I was especially excited to see cannoli on their menu. It was good and I could tell it was not pre-made because the shell was still crispy when I bit into it.

Published a year ago

True New York slices served here

Published a year ago

So I decided to take a chance on this location due to the fact it was one of the few places open on Christmas. I should’ve taken heed to the previous substandard reviews. I ordered an Xtra large 5 cheese pepperoni pizza, 10 honey bbq wings, and an order of potato wedges. The potato wedges seemed to be tasteless and refried in old oil. The wings had to be doctored with other seasonings. The cheese pizza was below average and not worth the nearly $40!!!
I’m gonna chalk this experience up to it being on Christmas Day. There was no enjoyment for this food while watching Christmas Day football and basketball. I gave this location a one star because it was actually open on Christmas Day. Buyers and Italian food lovers beware!!!

Published a year ago

Published a year ago

Published a year ago

I liked the variety of toppings they had as well as the crust. They can do half half but you have to call. Garlic knots looked like a ton of flavor but was on the bland side however the dough was good. The boneless wings with bbq didn’t taste like bbq at all. Overall just okay.

Published a year ago

Published a year ago

BOMB!!! My family and I loved it after my daughter's competition :) recommend it!

Published a year ago

Best NY style in the area for sure.

Published a year ago

Was surprised by the respectable prices. Ma & Pa pizza shops usually charge a lot more, as most people are fine paying for cheap chain pizza made of ingredients from a factory. To go with the food prices is a great pizza! Way better than expected. The $8.99 for 2 slices and a soda is perfect for the after school kids to meet up after school. My son said it was some of the best garlic toast he's ever had too. I will be returning.

Published a year ago

I had two LARGE Slices of mushroom, sausage and pepperoni pizza. Delicious 😋 I'll be back again soon. The hard part will be deciding what to have. I want more pizza, but there are so many other things on the menu that look So Good!

Published a year ago

Published a year ago

The food was absolutely amazing, I'm normally very picky about the bread used for pizza but the one I got was almost like a well done thin crust. Crunchy, full of sauce and topping they don't hold back like other places I've been to. The atmosphere of the place gives it a really chill vibe. If you have the time and sizable party I definitely recommend stopping by here. Plus I won a little box from the claw machine which is rare for me :D

Published a year ago

Published 2 years ago

The pizza here was AMAZING. i like it.

omar

Published 2 years ago

I highly recommend this place. I had the Meatball sandwich, And a Pastrami sandwich. Both were excellent!
Thanks for helping me to my car sir...

Published 2 years ago

This pizza is bomb, Omar is a very friendly owner and definitely knows how to make great pizza. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone looking to get a proper slice.

Published 2 years ago

Published 2 years ago

Best NY style pizza in the arcadia area!

Published 2 years ago

Pizza was pretty average. pricing is deceptive since the total prices aren't advertised just, the make your own. While waiting, the tables were pretty dirty.

Published 2 years ago

Es un lugar normal con un producto de buen sabor

Published 2 years ago

Published 2 years ago

the staff is waaaay to slow to take your order i dont recommend it

Published 2 years ago

Best pizza place in Arcadia!!! Anytime we want pizza that's the only place to go! Quality of the pizza is delicious! Wings are great and their potato wedges are the absolute best!! Anything you get here is delicious so give them a try. Also they sell some by the slice, another great way to taste some of their pizza!

Published 2 years ago

Published 2 years ago

We really love Omar's pizza in Arcadia. They have really great pizza and I highly recommend you try their fettuccine Alfredo it's delicious!

Published 2 years ago

Good local West Coast pizza (New York style but better); big flavor that doesn't leave you bloated. It's our family's go-to pizza spot! The crust is delicious, the tomato sauce is well balanced and not too acidic, and the cheese doesn't slough off the slices. The pepperoni is slightly less than medium spicy and might be too much to handle for some much younger kiddos. They don't sell alcohol since they are so close to a high school but they do sell pretty yummy chocolate chip cookies. No public bathrooms.

Published 2 years ago

Published 2 years ago

Food is really good, especially the fettuccine alfredo and baked ziti.

Published 3 years ago

I've lived in NYC and Chicago. I generally like most pizza, but only love a certain few. Realy tasty NY style cheese. This is easily top 3 in SoCal. Solid work Omar, solid work.

Published 3 years ago

Good food

Published 3 years ago

I do not recommend this restaurant. Ordered a combination slice, the piece of pizza was riddled with olives. The whole piece taste like a nasty cheesy Olive mess. They advertise many different slices, but when you get there they say you have to order the whole pizza. They only offer cheese, pepperoni, combination, and Hawaiian only. Other than the olives the slice of pizza had no taste. Thumbs down 👎👎

Published 3 years ago

Omar has been a family favorite for a long time. You can't go wrong with the pizza here. My dad used to go here all the time.

Definitely go with the white artichoke if you've never been. It's a super special pizza with unique flavors and sauce, I've never been anywhere with anything like it. I think the works pizza is usually my favorite because I love the red onions. They also have amazing cookies that are soft, chewy, and not too sweet. Definitely recommend eating these pizzas fresh and hot, that's the best way to have them.

The Bleu cheese dressing is the best of all the pizza places that I've ever been to but I'm sad that they didn't have their pesto when I went.

I would love to go back and try the calzones because I've never had a great calzone but I'm confident that they would make amazing calzones.

Published 3 years ago

Margarita pizza is very good. Cant wait to try the other pizza specials. The calzones.

Published 3 years ago

Increased lunch special price and added credit card fees. Pizza was old and less flavorful.

Published 3 years ago

Always good and hot! Love their website ordering and the coupon is always appreciated! Thanks Omar's!!!

Published 3 years ago

Published 3 years ago

Pizza Artists! Cant drive by on the Freeway and not stop.

Published 3 years ago

Our family loves this local neighborhood pizza joint in Arcadia. Their homemade sauce and cheese is unique and delicious. They have huge pizza sizes and even sell by the slice ($3.50), which are huge! They have specialty pizza like The Bronx, which is my favorite.

Published 3 years ago

Delicious! They were very accommodating for our party of 20.

Published 3 years ago

Great food 😋

Published 3 years ago

Best Pizza in Town.....PERIOD! Make sure you try the wings, the are my absolute favorite! Side Note....The accidentally forgot my potato wedges with my order, before I could even get home they called me to tell me. That's great customer service!

Published 3 years ago

Great little eatery. Great prices and the servings are for sharing...learned that the hard way. Staff is very friendly and helpful. The food was great. Definitely a place we will come back to.

Published 3 years ago

Very good pizza here. Definitely recommend.

Published 3 years ago

Published 3 years ago

I only ever eat calzones here. I order from here about once a month and absolutely love their calzones, only place around this area to get good calzones! :D

Published 3 years ago

This is a professional pizza shop. There are many kinds of pizza with good taste. In addition, there are many Mexican salads with good taste. There are not many people sitting in the hall. Many people come to take away

Published 3 years ago

Ni para que calificar.hize un pedido de espagueti y una orden de presas de pollo.en la aplicación que ellos manejan se veía que venía el espaguetti con carne.total que pido delivery para que me traigan la comida..pagando todavía para que me traigan mi comida y cuando recibo la comida.y veo la comida eran presas de pollo secas quemadas sin sabor insipidas.sin nisiquiera una salsa ranchs.y lo peor el espaguetti me Yego sin carne.era solo espaguetti y salsa roja....que porquería de servicio.

Published 3 years ago

Published 3 years ago

Pretty good. Was my first time here and tried the cannanoli. Will come back to try the pizza which smelled good while I was there.

Published 3 years ago

Published 3 years ago

Published 4 years ago

Published 4 years ago

Pizza is good for the price

Published 4 years ago

Published 4 years ago

Published 4 years ago

It I could give them 0 stars I would, yesterday I order for my patient, she’s 91 years old, and we were waiting for 2 hours, finally after our 4th call they said “we don’t have your order, you can order now or go somewhere else “ that was really rude, he said he was Omar

Published 4 years ago

Classic and original taste. Beats the heck out of Pappa Johns. Thank you guys!

Published 4 years ago

I liked the crust and the cheese. Sauce was ok as well.

Published 4 years ago

Born and raised in NYC and tbh their pizza is alright. I wouldn't call it NY style but somewhat close. (Not really). I order a large pie with the hope of getting a NY style pizza and tbh the cheese tasted a little funny like it was expired 2 days ago. The chicken wasn't fresh and it tasted something you ate at elementary school cafeteria. Friendly staff but I wouldn't get my hopes up if you are expecting NY style pizza. Just my 2cents..

Published 4 years ago

One of the best in SGV
Authentic NY style pie.

Published 4 years ago

It's a good place to order from. Pizza is really good. Prefer this pizza over bigger chain location's. Phone and in house assistance from staff needs work but food is good.

Published 4 years ago

Published 4 years ago

Best pizza in the area.

Published 4 years ago

Published 4 years ago

For some reason this is the first time I've ever been to Omars pizza was very very good I look forward to going again.

Published 4 years ago

I ordered lasagna it was the best ever.called them back and Thank them.i highly recommend OMARS.last time i went there horrible.lost my business

Published 5 years ago

Perhaps we tried this on an off night. There's something about the dough that's off. The crust and the garlic knots were not good. Crust was too well done. The garlic knots were cooked just right, but tasted very dry. So the food alone, I give them 3 stars. I knocked another star off because they didn't prepare the pizza right. They took my phone order correctly (sausage and mushroom) as shown to me on the order slip, but ended up putting pepperoni instead. The person helping said it happens sometimes when they are busy. Thus the free garlic knots. We wanted to really like this place and decided to try it and skip our regular spot, now we'll just be going back to our regular spot.

Published 4 years ago

I was apprehensive of this spot, after looking at the prices and some of the other negative reviews. I decided to take a chance because I was really craving a good calzone (insert Parks & Rec meme). Having used to work at a family-owned NY/NJ style that made calzones, my standards were set pretty high.

When I got my order of knots and the calzone, I was blown away. The Calzone itself was baked to perfection, the toppings were plentiful and the cheese gooey. Not to mention the seasoning on top to finish it off was nothing short of BEAUTIFUL. The knots were a bit smaller than I'd hoped for being 4 dollars but what they lacked in size they made up for in taste and seasoning. Marinara sauce is nothing to write home about but it's much better than the chains. The (presumably) homemade ranch was a little thicker than I would have liked but nonetheless was great. All in all, I'll be ordering here again. You guys have blown me away as a first time customer, well done lads.

Published 4 years ago

Love the pizza dough...the works is my favorite.

Published 4 years ago

This place is SO GOOD!
Try it guys!
If it wasn’t for COVID, I might not discover this little gem in Arcadia.

Give it a try, fresh thin dough. Great sauce, fresh ingredients!

Published 4 years ago

My boyfriend and I decided to try Omar's during quarantine and now we get it twice a month. It would be more if I had the metabolism lol. I honestly can't speak for the pizza because I got their italian calzone and it was so good everytime we order i get it again. My boyfriend loves the spaghetti and their garlic knots are also delicious. 10/10 would recommend! 👌 👍

Published 4 years ago

Published 5 years ago

This place is hidden gem, their medium pizza served 3. We tried bbq chicken which came with ample toppings. Definitely recommend it for low budget happy dinning. Good value for money

Published 4 years ago

I just went to Omar's for the first time and I ordered the Meatball sandwich. I am a huge meatball lover and it's hard to find a really good one. This sandwich is the best damn Meatball sandwich I've ever had. The sauce was thick and sweet and the parmasean and cheese melted over it, it was heaven in my mouth. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND Omar's Pizza!!

Published 5 years ago

El presidenté, Dave Portnoy would approve.

Published 5 years ago

Won’t recommend!!They didn’t make the pizza as I ordered and the cook even repeated the order correctly and still the pizza was wrong and then started to argue about it and get very rude and disrespectful towards me! He even started to talk down to me like I was stupid! I don’t know what happened to this place it went down hill!

Published 5 years ago

We ordered a pizza on the phone. When I went to pick it up he told me to wait cause it wasn’t ready. Since we are on quarantine I waited outside. That’s when a guy came bringing back a pizza. The worker than said ok your order is ready and tried to give me the returned pizza. He said he accidentally gave my pizza to the wrong customer but that it’s all there and the guy brought it back for me! Are you kidding me! I said you cannot give me a returned pizza and asked for my money back! The worker was very upset with ME!

Published 5 years ago

Published 5 years ago

Tasty and delicious New York style pizza!

Published 5 years ago

Ask for your pie, "crispy" and it's as close to Brooklyn Style NY pizza as I've had outside of NY. The crust will snap when you fold it. There's no bathroom for eating in, so just get it to-go.

Published 5 years ago

Yummm.. & good customer service

Published 5 years ago

Published 6 years ago

Great service, very friendly and most importantly really good pizza. Love it

Published 5 years ago

Best New York Style Pizza in San Gabriel Valley. Delicious!

Published 5 years ago

SERIOUSLY WALKED IN ON ACCIDENT AND FOUND A REAL SLICE OF PIZZA TRY FOR YOURSELF WORDS WON'T SUFFICE THE SIMPLICITY NEW YORK STYLE ßR○○KLYN KEVIN DURANT STYLE FUTUREŞ

Published 5 years ago

Loved their pizzas!

Published 5 years ago

Nice pizza by the slice deals, so great for lunch!

Published 5 years ago

Published 5 years ago

Published 5 years ago

Good food.

Published 5 years ago

The reheated slices taste like I just microwaved a Red Baron frozen pizza. I remember when this placed was located on Huntington Drive and was delicious. How times have changed.

Published 5 years ago

There garlic knotts are great, if you love garlic, you will love it.

Published 5 years ago

Published 5 years ago

Just found this place since my buddy wanted some pizza. Found it on Yelp, read the reviews and gave it a shot. The pizza tasted great. It was New York style pizza and the sauce and toppings had a ton of flavor. I only wished I ordered another pizza.

Published 5 years ago

Published 5 years ago

Awesome!!!

Published 5 years ago

Nice pizza

Published 5 years ago

Published 5 years ago

Published 5 years ago

Pizza was good but no air condition so get it to go

Published 6 years ago

Good pizza, bad ravioli

Published 6 years ago

Really good flavor on pizza
And the pastas so delicious 😋👍

Published 6 years ago

Published 6 years ago

Published 6 years ago

Published 6 years ago

Pizza quality has gone downhill. The dough tastes pre made or frozen. How I long for the days when guys would hand toss he dough.
Not what it used to be!

Published 6 years ago

It has much potential, its location is rough but great customer service and food quality for the price was fair.

Published 6 years ago

Published 6 years ago

Published 6 years ago

best pizza ever

Published 6 years ago

This place used to be Uncle Reds, and it was amazing. New owners and new business name unfortunately also came with menu changes. The price for toppings is crazy once you taste the quality of the ingredients. To bulid your own pizza is pricy and not worth the extra money. This place does not make the cut any longer

Published 7 years ago

Published 6 years ago

The pastrami sandwich is bomb!😋

Published 6 years ago

Published 6 years ago

Love the Italian calzone & Whitestone + extra garlic

Published 6 years ago

Published 6 years ago

Published 6 years ago

We always usually order from here cuz the pizza is great but NEVER again because the staff is waaaay to slow to take your order OR they leave you on hold for 6 minutes or more while they are chatting in the background!!!

Published 6 years ago

Meatball sandwich!! This is the best place for meatball sandwiches!

Published 6 years ago

Very good

Published 6 years ago

Great pizza unfortunately it is over priced

Published 6 years ago

Published 6 years ago

Very good pizza, tasty crust, cheesy, and good topping distribution. The chicken wings were great, crispy skin and good sauce, way better than I usually expect from a pizza place. Delivered just when they said they would. Would order again.

Published 6 years ago

Good pizza

Published 6 years ago

Delicious and unique taste

Published 6 years ago

Edited Review:
Knocked them down to a three, thanks to the owner. Made a rude, snarky comment saying I owe him money because his employee under-charged me by $5 the week before. I'm leaving my original review below, because it is good pizza; but, the business lost my 2-3 orders per week because of the owner.

Amazing food accompanied with great service. So far, I've eaten their buffalo wings, calzone, pizza, and salad. Wings have a different spice and kick than other restaurants. Calzone and pizza portions are large and valuable. Salad is only thing I can't rave about, it's a regular traditional green salad topped with red onion, olives, and tomatoes. Definitely my favorite pizza in my area and a must try.

Published 6 years ago

Good and delicious

Published 6 years ago

I just discovered this place, and it's amazing!!! I will definitely be a regular customer!!!

Published 6 years ago

The Pizza Was Great! And We Had these yummy garlic bread puffs?! So delish!

Published 6 years ago

I would rather you that the post pizza About a mile away In El Monte it's the best pizza ever had.

Published 8 years ago

My new go to pizzeria place in town. The food I had were all one of the best. Calzone, alfredo pasta, lasagna were so full of flavor and delicious. Their marinara sauce... I am drooling as I think about it again. I took out a star because the food took too long to come out in the hall. The guy was very nice to apologize about it though. However, I think I will go back for the food. It s worth the waiting.

Published 6 years ago

Very good garlic bread, warm crispy on the outside. Pizza was great to, beats any of those large chain pizza places and the service was friendly.

Published 6 years ago

Pizza 🍕 pizza read all about it it's super cheesey and has loads of toppings

Published 6 years ago

My friend and family were on our way home from the Renaissance fair and stopped by here. Very tasty pizza and friendly service.

Published 6 years ago

Good pizza, funny, friendly staff.

Published 6 years ago

Love this place

Published 6 years ago

Great pizza, loads of cheese and other toppings. Quick and friendly service.

Published 6 years ago

I have been buying pizza for my school parties for over 18 years. I stumbled upon Uncle Red's website because one of my students wanted calzone. I ordered 2 jumbo pizzas and 2 calzones and antipasto. It was delivered right on time by a super nice delivery man. Brought it back to my classroom and the kiddos started eating and their eyes popped out of their heads! I have never seen them look so happy about pizza, a they loooove pizza! They were over the moon. Staff started hearing about how good it was and by the end of lunch my party had doubled in size!!!! I will definitely be back!!!!

Published 7 years ago

Published 7 years ago

很好吃 还会再来哦

delicious

Published 7 years ago

Published 7 years ago

Very good crust, yummy😊

Published 7 years ago

Published 7 years ago

Just discovered this place and it is great!

The building is nondescript, but the interior is clean, well lit and has the ambiance of a traditional pizza/Italian place.

The pizza is fantastic, with excellent crust, tasty sauce and very generous toppings. Seriously, the pizza is COVERED in toppings!

Prices are very fair for the amount of food you receive, and the service was fast.

I loved my first experience here and can't wait to go back!

Published 7 years ago

wonderful pizza. Doing a very good job.

Published 7 years ago

My boyfriend said his pizza was average but my breadsticks were absolutely amazing. Would recommend.

Published 7 years ago

I owned a pizza place in for over 23 years and I'm constantly on the look out for good pizza. This place was kind of hard to find but it's worth the effort, great pizza! The best crust, tasty pizza sauce and lots of cheese.

Published 7 years ago

Published 7 years ago

Published 7 years ago

Delicious pizza!!

Published 7 years ago

ordered 9 pizzas last minute because friend recommended Reds. Great. Good pizza. They even called later to asked if i was satisfied. Ill be back

Published 8 years ago

Pretty nondescript place with excellent pizza. Obviously quality ingredients and generous toppings. It isn't the cheapest thing around, but you definitely get what you pay for!

Published 8 years ago

Really good pizza and a friendly staff!

Published 8 years ago

Awesome place, great food enough said.

Published 8 years ago

This place is good. Their pizza is exceptional, one of the best in the area. Their other items are pretty good too and they are priced right to make Uncle Reds a great choice for a week night take out dinner when it's too late or you are too tired to cook. The ingredients taste very fresh and not overly greasy or salty.

Published 8 years ago

Greetings from the Hampton Inn Hotel in Arcadia!!! If you want good pizza, then this is the place. The pizzas are delicious and they are very generous with their toppings. I really recommend Uncle Red's pizza to our guest before any other pizza restaurant.... Thank you Alberto for making great pizzas!!!

Published 8 years ago